I have my list, do you have yours? (Granted, I have not yet seen all of the current Oscar contenders. Plus, I prefer to watch movies that are 20 years old or more.)
No specific order:
The Departed
The Descent
Thank You For Smoking
Sweet Land
Apocolypto
Casino Royale (never thought I would have a Bond movie here)
Little Miss Sunshine
United 93
Pan's Labyrinth
The Pursuit of Happyness
Geez, for a horror guy there's not a lot of horror up there. That tells me a little something...
*mike



You forgot two great horror
You forgot two great horror films:
Slither
&
Feast (even though imdb says 2005 the theatrical run wasn't till 06)
Hard Candy is an 06 as well. Fantastic film.
There was a couple of other films that I'd call good but not the best.